| 5. "Medicine Before Automation"
 In
1961, Dr. William Shainline Middleton (University of Pennsylvania M.D., 1911 and
Hon. Sc.D., 1946) delivered a speech called "Medicine Before Automation"
at the Certificate Ceremony of the Graduate School of Medicine. He stated that
the advent of advanced biomedical equipment and computer technology posed great
opportunities for the practice of medicine as a science. At the same time, he
feared that dependence on such equipment might destroy the practice of medicine
as an art. Middleton said that what defined the physicians of his own and earlier
generations was dependence on their clinical experience to make diagnoses. While
some theorists might complain that such an attitude elevated clinical practice
to a state of mystical experience, Middleton stated that the intuitions and deductive
reasoning used by the doctors that educated him were products of a "biologic"
computer, the human brain, and the languages upon which they relied to make such
diagnoses were those of the normal and abnormal operations of the human body,
an infinitely complex machine.
Shainline's
address skillfully identified two important attitudes of physicians towards computers,
that computers are human creations that imitate living structures, and that computers
must be never used at a crutch for the physician. Both attitudes have shaped the
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine's use of computers. |